1991 Fleer Ultra Football Cards Most Valuable
The 1991 Fleer Ultra Football set marked Fleer’s entry into the premium card segment, offering cleaner designs, upgraded photography, and better card stock compared to standard issues of the era. While it may not rival the popularity of Topps or Score sets from the early '90s, collectors still hunt for mint-condition gems in PSA 10, especially for Hall of Famers and rookies.
Based on PSA 10 sales data and population reports, we’ve compiled a list of the most valuable cards from the 1991 Fleer Ultra Football set. This list includes legendary Hall of Famers, iconic rookie cards, and standout players whose impact on the game is still felt today.
1. Barry Sanders #169
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $50–$75
PSA 10 Population: 60
Significance: One of the most electrifying running backs in NFL history, Barry Sanders dazzled fans with unmatched agility and vision. A 10-time Pro Bowler and 1997 NFL MVP, Sanders retired abruptly at the top of his game, finishing with over 15,000 rushing yards in just 10 seasons—all with the Detroit Lions. His cards are coveted for both his on-field excellence and the lasting mystique of a legend who walked away early.
2. Brett Favre #283 (Rookie)
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $30–$45
PSA 10 Population: 1,288
Significance: Though this rookie card shows Favre with the Falcons (where he barely played), it’s a cornerstone for collectors. Favre went on to become a three-time NFL MVP, a Super Bowl champion with the Packers, and the NFL’s all-time leader in multiple categories at retirement. His legendary iron-man streak of 297 consecutive starts at quarterback still stands.
3. Emmitt Smith #165
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $25–$35
PSA 10 Population: 103
Significance: Emmitt Smith is the NFL’s all-time leading rusher with 18,355 yards and 164 touchdowns. He won three Super Bowls with the Cowboys and claimed the 1993 NFL MVP award. Known for his toughness, vision, and consistency, Smith's legacy is cemented as one of the greatest backs of all time.
4. Jerry Rice #254
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $25–$30
PSA 10 Population: 85
Significance: Widely considered the greatest wide receiver in NFL history, Jerry Rice holds many of the major receiving records. A 13-time Pro Bowler and 3-time Super Bowl champion, Rice's incredible work ethic and production across two decades made him a collecting staple.
5. Deion Sanders #150
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $25–$30
PSA 10 Population: 42
Significance: "Prime Time" was a two-sport superstar known for his elite speed and lockdown coverage. A Hall of Fame cornerback and two-time Super Bowl champion, Deion was also a showman, influencing pop culture and redefining the role of a defensive playmaker.
6. Joe Montana #251
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $25–$30
PSA 10 Population: 113
Significance: Before Tom Brady, Joe Montana was the GOAT. A four-time Super Bowl champion and 2-time NFL MVP, Montana was legendary for his clutch performances, including “The Catch” and multiple game-winning drives. His cards remain iconic across all sets.
7. Troy Aikman #162
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $20–$30
PSA 10 Population: 51
Significance: The quarterback behind the Cowboys’ 1990s dynasty, Aikman led Dallas to three Super Bowl titles. Known for his poise and accuracy, Aikman’s leadership and consistency were crucial to the team’s dominance during the decade.
8. Herman Moore #291 (Rookie)
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $25
PSA 10 Population: 25
Significance: A top receiver in the 1990s, Moore was a four-time Pro Bowler and twice led the league in receptions. He was a reliable target for the Lions, setting franchise records before the arrival of Calvin Johnson.
9. John Elway #35
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $20–$25
PSA 10 Population: 77
Significance: Elway’s toughness and late-game heroics defined the Broncos through the ‘80s and ‘90s. He capped his career with back-to-back Super Bowl wins before retiring and later returned as an executive to lead Denver to another championship.
10. Ricky Watters #297 (Rookie)
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $20–$25
PSA 10 Population: 42
Significance: An explosive dual-threat back, Watters tallied over 10,000 rushing yards and 4,000 receiving yards in his career. He made five Pro Bowls and won a Super Bowl with the 49ers. His versatility helped shape the evolution of the modern NFL running back.
11. Dan Marino #88
Estimated PSA 10 Value: $20
PSA 10 Population: 68
Significance: Marino revolutionized the passing game with his lightning-fast release and cannon arm. Though he never won a Super Bowl, he retired with dozens of passing records and remains one of the most talented QBs to ever play the game.
Final Thoughts
The 1991 Fleer Ultra football set offers a nostalgic trip to the early ‘90s NFL, packed with Hall of Famers and a few underrated rookies. While print runs were high in the junk wax era, PSA 10s remain rare and somewhat valuable due to condition sensitivity and low submission rates. Whether you're chasing the Brett Favre rookie or hunting low-pop Barry Sanders cards, this set still has plenty to offer collectors.
