2023 Topps Series 1 Baseball Top Rookies (Most Valuable)
The 2023 Topps Series 1 Baseball set introduced collectors to a standout class of rookies, many of whom are already impacting Major League Baseball in major ways. As we navigate the 2025 season, the ranking of these rookie cards has evolved—shaped by player performance, collector demand, and market momentum. This list ranks the top rookies in 2023 Topps Series 1 using a combination of current base card value, on-field success, and long-term potential. This list only focuses on players who received a true base rookie card in the main checklist—not Rookie Debut cards.
Let’s dive into which rookies are worth watching—and collecting.
1. Gunnar Henderson #206 – Baltimore Orioles (SS/3B)
The reigning AL Rookie of the Year, Gunnar Henderson combines power, speed, and elite defensive versatility. In 2024, he took another step forward with a breakout power surge and improved plate discipline, notching 37 home runs. He’s become the cornerstone of a rising Orioles team and a fan favorite in the hobby.
2. Adley Rutschman #250 – Baltimore Orioles (C)
One of the most polished catchers in baseball, Rutschman brings leadership, game-calling, and offensive consistency. A switch-hitter with gap-to-gap power, he’s also the heart of Baltimore’s clubhouse. His on-base skills and ability to control the running game make him one of the most complete catchers in the game.
3. Riley Greene #31 – Detroit Tigers (OF)
Greene entered 2024 with high expectations, and he delivered. Known for his smooth left-handed swing, he hits for both average and power, and has flashed Gold Glove potential in center field. Injuries have been a concern, but when healthy, he’s one of the Tigers’ best offensive weapons.
4. Michael Harris II #226 – Atlanta Braves (OF)
Harris burst onto the scene with elite defense in center field and a potent combination of speed and bat-to-ball skills. He quickly earned a reputation for highlight-reel plays and offensive consistency. His ability to impact the game on both sides of the ball makes him one of the most exciting young players in the league—and a staple in the Braves’ lineup. His all-around athleticism and swagger make him a favorite in Atlanta.
5. Triston Casas #92 – Boston Red Sox (1B)
A disciplined slugger with a great eye at the plate, Casas combines patience and raw power from the left side. He’s known for working deep counts and drawing walks while driving the ball with authority. A physical presence at first base, he has the tools to become a fixture in the middle of Boston’s lineup for years to come.
6. Vinnie Pasquantino #302 – Kansas City Royals (1B)
Pasquantino brings a unique blend of polish and personality to the big leagues. Often described as a “thinking man’s slugger,” he combines sharp pitch recognition with gap-to-gap power and underrated athleticism for his position. More than just a bat, he's earned respect for his leadership and clubhouse presence.
7. Hunter Brown #111 – Houston Astros (P)
Brown is a hard-throwing right-hander with electric stuff and front-of-the-rotation upside. With a fastball that touches the upper 90s and a sharp breaking ball, he’s shown the ability to miss bats and work deep into games.
8. Brayan Bello #185 – Boston Red Sox (P)
Bello is a right-handed pitcher with a devastating sinker-changeup combo and impressive poise on the mound. He generates ground balls and weak contact, making him a reliable presence in the rotation. His ability to command multiple pitches and adjust during outings has earned him praise as one of Boston’s most promising young arms.
9. Nolan Gorman #16 – St. Louis Cardinals (2B)
Gorman is a left-handed power hitter with serious home run upside. Originally drafted as a third baseman, he transitioned to second base while keeping his bat in the lineup. His ability to drive the ball deep to all fields gives him long-term appeal, especially if he can improve his consistency at the plate.
10. Brett Baty #89 – New York Mets (3B)
Baty boasts a sweet left-handed swing and some power. He’s shown flashes of offensive brilliance and continues to refine his defense at third base. With a tall frame and quick hands, he projects as a high-upside hitter capable of anchoring the Mets' infield if he puts it all together.
Other Notable Rookies
⚾ Ivan Herrera #58 – St. Louis Cardinals (C)
⚾ Gabriel Moreno #169 – Toronto Blue Jays (C)
⚾ Shea Langeliers #127 – Oakland Athletics (C)
⚾ Jonathan Aranda #154 – Tampa Bay Rays (2B/1B)
⚾ Miguel Vargas #163 – Los Angeles Dodgers (1B)
⚾ Kyle Stowers #156 – Baltimore Orioles (OF)
⚾ Nolan Jones #129 – Cleveland Guardians (OF)
⚾ Christopher Morel #308 – Chicago Cubs (2B/OF)
Final Thoughts
The 2023 Topps Series 1 rookie checklist is packed with potential stars. Whether you're chasing short-term value or building a collection of future All-Stars, these rookies offer a compelling mix of skill, personality, and potential. Their cards are not just rookie labels—they're the beginning of what could become legacy collections.
As the seasons unfold, these players will continue to shape both the sport and the hobby. Be sure to keep a close eye on their progress—and their rookie cards.
