2023 Topps Series 2 Baseball Top Rookies (Most Valuable)
2023 Topps Series 2 Baseball brought collectors a new wave of rookie cards featuring some of the game's brightest young stars. Whether you're collecting for investment or team pride, this set includes players already making a significant impact on the field. Below, we highlight the top 10 most valuable rookies in the release and break down what makes each of them special. This list only focuses on players who received a true base rookie card in the main checklist—not Rookie Debut or insert cards.
💡 These rankings are based on a mix of current card value, long-term potential, and the players’ accomplishments early in their careers.
1. Corbin Carroll #401 – Arizona Diamondbacks (OF)
Corbin Carroll exploded onto the MLB scene with elite speed, defensive range, and surprising power. The 2023 NL Rookie of the Year helped lead the Diamondbacks to the World Series, becoming the first rookie in MLB history to have 25+ home runs and 50+ stolen bases in a season. Carroll’s all-around skillset and fearless playstyle have already made him a franchise cornerstone and hobby favorite.
2. Anthony Volpe #460 – New York Yankees (SS)
As the first rookie shortstop in Yankees history to hit 20+ home runs and steal 20+ bases in a season, Volpe brings rare power-speed potential to one of baseball’s most iconic franchises. His defense also earned him a Gold Glove in 2023. With elite instincts and leadership, Volpe is already viewed as a foundational piece in New York's future plans.
3. Kerry Carpenter #394 – Detroit Tigers (OF/DH)
Carpenter was one of the bright spots for Detroit in 2023, showcasing impressive raw power and run-producing ability. He finished the season with 20+ home runs and a strong OPS, providing middle-of-the-lineup stability. While not as hyped as some peers, his consistent bat has drawn attention in the hobby.
4. Ezequiel Tovar #651 – Colorado Rockies (SS)
Tovar impressed in his rookie season with elite defensive play and surprising pop from the shortstop position. He finished near the top of the league in defensive metrics at his position and flashed 15+ home run potential. Playing in Coors Field also gives his offensive ceiling added intrigue among collectors.
5. Jordan Walker #344 – St. Louis Cardinals (3B/OF)
One of the most hyped rookies entering 2023, Walker quickly made waves with his bat. Standing 6'6" with huge raw power, he had a record-setting 12-game hitting streak to start his MLB career. While still refining his defense, his offensive ceiling and age (just 21 during his rookie season) make him a long-term investment favorite.
6. Logan O'Hoppe #363 – Los Angeles Angels (C)
Despite a mid-season shoulder injury, O’Hoppe showed why the Angels were excited about him. He hit double-digit home runs in limited at-bats and displayed leadership behind the plate. With solid framing skills and a strong bat, O’Hoppe is poised to be one of the game’s top young catchers.
7. Mark Vientos #550 – New York Mets (3B)
Vientos brings serious slugging ability to the Mets' lineup. Though his MLB debut had ups and downs, he has a track record of demolishing Triple-A pitching and is seen as a potential everyday power bat. If his defense and plate discipline improve, his hobby value could rise significantly.
8. Josh Jung #529 – Texas Rangers (3B)
Jung had a breakout 2023 campaign and played a key role in the Texas Rangers’ World Series championship run. A former first-round pick, he earned an All-Star selection in his rookie year thanks to a balanced combination of power, contact, and clutch defense at third base. He’s already becoming a fan favorite in Texas.
9. Yainer Diaz #635 – Houston Astros (1B/C)
Diaz quietly had one of the most productive rookie seasons among catchers, batting over .280 with 20+ home runs. His bat-first profile and ability to play multiple positions (including first base and DH) make him a unique and valuable asset. As he gets more playing time in a stacked Astros lineup, his card values could climb quickly.
10. Francisco Alvarez #644 – New York Mets (C)
Alvarez entered 2023 as one of baseball’s top catching prospects and showcased elite power with 25+ home runs. While his batting average fluctuated, his raw strength and arm talent behind the plate make him a franchise-caliber backstop. At just 21 years old in his rookie season, Alvarez has huge upside and long-term appeal.
Other Notable Rookies
⚾ Brice Turang #530 – Milwaukee Brewers (SS)
⚾ Kodai Senga #362 – New York Mets (P)
⚾ Matt Wallner #448 – Minnesota Twins (OF)
⚾ Masataka Yoshida #471 – Boston Red Sox (OF)
⚾ Garrett Mitchell #359 – Milwaukee Brewers (OF)
⚾ Spencer Steer #489 – Cincinnati Reds (2B/3B)
⚾ Will Benson #339 – Cincinnati Reds (OF)
⚾ Bo Naylor #421 – Cleveland Guardians (C)
Final Thoughts
2023 Topps Series 2 Baseball has proven to be a key release for modern rookie cards, featuring players who are already shaping the future of the game. Whether you're chasing potential MVP candidates like Corbin Carroll or World Series heroes like Josh Jung, this set offers a great mix of star power, upside, and collectability. As with all rookie classes, values can fluctuate—but these 10 names have already laid strong foundations for hobby relevance.
