Top 10 Most Valuable 1991 Upper Deck Baseball Cards (With PSA 10 Prices)
The 1991 Upper Deck baseball set remains one of the most iconic releases of the early '90s. Known for its superior photography, sharp design, and memorable players, many cards from this set are still in high demand today—especially in PSA 10 (Gem Mint) condition. Whether you're a nostalgic collector or an investor, here are the top 10 most valuable cards from the 1991 Upper Deck baseball series, along with their significance and recent PSA 10 market values.
1. 1991 Upper Deck #SP1 Michael Jordan
PSA 10 Value: $350 - $450
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $7,600 (2021)
Significance: This is arguably the crown jewel of the set. It features NBA legend Michael Jordan taking batting practice with the Chicago White Sox, representing one of the most famous cross-sport moments in trading card history. Despite being a short print, it was printed in large numbers, but high-grade copies remain highly collectible.
2. 1991 Upper Deck #SP2 "A Day to Remember" (Rickey Henderson & Nolan Ryan)
PSA 10 Value: $50 - $90
Highest PSA 10 Sale: (Autographed Version) $3,300 (2025)
Significance: This card commemorates an extraordinary day in baseball history—May 1, 1991—when Rickey Henderson broke the all-time stolen base record and Nolan Ryan threw his seventh no-hitter. A card that immortalizes two Hall of Fame achievements in one frame.
3. 1991 Upper Deck #367 Lou Whitaker
PSA 10 Value: $55
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $57 (2024)
Significance: An undervalued legend and fan favorite, Whitaker was one of the best second basemen of his generation and is beloved by Tigers fans.
4. 1991 Upper Deck #636 Lou Brock, Ricky Henderson
[No Date on Front] PSA 10 Value: $25 - $55
[Date on Front] PSA 10 Value: $35 - $45
Significance: A beautiful tribute card featuring two of baseball’s greatest base stealers together. It's a must-have for fans of speed and historic milestones.
5. 1991 Upper Deck #175 Fernando Valenzuela
PSA 10 Value: $50
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $58 (2025)
Significance: Celebrates "Fernandomania" and Valenzuela's continued success and popularity, especially among Dodgers fans and Latin American collectors.
6. 1991 Upper Deck #444 Rickey Henderson
PSA 10 Value: $40 - $50
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $171.50 (2021)
Significance: This unique triple-image action shot of Henderson perfectly illustrates his speed and base-stealing prowess. It pays tribute to the all-time leader in stolen bases.
7. 1991 Upper Deck #55 Chipper Jones Rookie Card
PSA 10 Value: $40 - $50
Highest PSA 10 Sale: (Autographed Version) $780 (2021)
Significance: This card showcases a young Chipper Jones, who would go on to be one of the best switch-hitters in MLB history and a first-ballot Hall of Famer. A true cornerstone rookie card for collectors.
8. 1991 Upper Deck #445 Will Clark
PSA 10 Value: $40 - $45
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $54 (2023)
Significance: "The Thrill" was one of the most exciting hitters of his era. This card captures him at the height of his career.
9. 1991 Upper Deck #155 Jose Canseco
PSA 10 Value: $40 - $45
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $47 (2023)
Significance: Canseco was one of the biggest names in baseball in the early '90s. This card is a reminder of his power-hitting days and star power.
10. 1991 Upper Deck #555 Ken Griffey Jr.
PSA 10 Value: $30 - $45
Highest PSA 10 Sale: $244 (2021)
Significance: "The Kid" is captured here in his classic batting stance, full of charisma and promise. Griffey Jr. became one of the most beloved and talented players of his generation, and this card celebrates his early career.
Honorable Mentions
These cards may not be in the Top 10 but are still very collectible and can command decent value in PSA 10 condition:
#345 Nolan Ryan - PSA 10 Value: $25 - $40
#11 Bernie Williams Rookie Card - PSA 10 Value: $25 - $35
#246 Frank Thomas Rookie Card - PSA 10 Value: $25 - $30
#744 Bo Jackson - PSA 10 Value: $25 - $30
Final Thoughts
While the 1991 Upper Deck set was massively produced during the "junk wax" era, these particular cards continue to hold value due to the significance of the players, historic moments captured, and the challenge of finding them in PSA 10 condition. For collectors and baseball enthusiasts, these cards are timeless reminders of one of baseball's most memorable decades.