How Much Is A Signed Baseball By Mickey Mantle Worth?
Mantle was one of baseball’s true legends, a Hall of Famer, a key part of the great New York Yankees dynasty, and an autograph magnet. That legacy means his signed baseballs can carry significant value, but the exact price depends on multiple variables. Here’s a breakdown.
At a Glance: The Value Range
Typical range (authentic, single-signed): ~$350 - $12,000+, depending on signature strength, ball condition, and sweet-spot placement (PSA’s price guide lists Mantle single-signed baseballs at $350 (PSA 7), $600 (PSA 8), $1,100 (PSA 9), and $3,000 (PSA 10). (PSA)
Mantle Sales That Broke $10K
$12,000 - Mickey Mantle Single-Signed Baseball with "2401 G's" Inscription PSA/DNA NM-MT 8 with MINT 9 Signature Grade (Summer 2024). Collectrea
$10,800 - 1949-51 Mickey Mantle Single Signed Baseball (December 2024). Heritage Auctions
$22,800 - Mickey Mantle Signed & Inscribed ONL White Baseball with "F*** the National League" Inscription (JSA) (2021). Goldin Auctions
Prices fluctuate with supply, presentation, and timing. Use recent comps and third-party grades to anchor expectations.
Recent Lower-End Sales (Heavily Aged or Faded Examples)
$360 - Mickey Mantle Single-Signed Baseball - JSA (June 2025) Collectrea
$312 - Mickey Mantle Single Signed Baseball - JSA (December 2024) Heritage Auctions
$275 - Mickey Mantle Signed Baseball - JSA LOA (October 2025) Goldin Auctions
These examples highlight the low-end reality of Mantle's autograph market: authenticity alone doesn’t guarantee a high price. Factors like fading, restoration, ball condition, and overall presentation can pull an otherwise legendary signature down into the low hundreds range, still valuable, but far removed from the museum-quality pieces that command five-figure sums.
The Final Word: Why Mantle’s Signature Still Reigns Supreme
More than three decades after his passing, Mickey Mantle’s autograph remains one of the crown jewels of baseball collecting. While prices swing from a few hundred dollars to well into five figures, every Mantle-signed baseball tells a story, one of Yankee Stadium’s golden years, of power and grace, of a legend who defined postwar baseball.
For collectors, the takeaway is simple: condition and authentication matter most. A clean sweet-spot signature with PSA or JSA certification will always command respect and often, a premium.